查看文章

Overall, The Tenth Justice offers an important window into not only the legalities of the Nadon case but also the politics behind it. The book weaves together political, historical, and legal insights to paint a picture about this saga in Canadian history. The authors strive to make the legal aspects accessible to lay readers, but those who struggle with the legal nuances will still be satisfied. Indeed, the main insight of this book is what it means for future Canadian judicial appointments. If the Nadon case lifted the veil on the politics of Supreme Court appointments, how should Canadians manage the process going forward? Those reading this text will be well equipped to answer this important question. But we are left wondering why and how Marc Nadon was a problem to begin with. mark mancini University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada