[HTML][HTML] Response to critique of:'Understanding the impact of lockdowns on short-term excess mortality in Australia'by Gigi Foster and Sanjeev Sabhlok

P Clarke, A Leigh - BMJ Global Health, 2023 - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Our paper 1 studies the impact of lockdowns in Australia on short-term mortality. Our study
finds that, compared with the period 2015–2019, the standardised mortality rate in 2020 …

Response to 'Understanding the impact of lockdowns on short-term excess mortality in Australia'by Philip Clarke and Andrew Leigh (published in BMJ Global Health)

G Foster, S Sabhlok - BMJ Global Health, 2023 - gh.bmj.com
PROBLEM 1: ASKING THE WRONG QUESTION Estimating short-term excess mortality
effects cannot tell us whether lockdowns were a good idea. The conventional approach to …

Understanding the impact of lockdowns on short-term excess mortality in Australia

P Clarke, A Leigh - BMJ Global Health, 2022 - gh.bmj.com
During 2020 and 2021, Australia implemented relatively stringent government restrictions
yet had few COVID-19 deaths. This provides an opportunity to understand the effects of …

Leicester lockdown: could better data have prevented it?

J Wise - bmj, 2020 - bmj.com
Leicester lockdown: could better data have prevented it? | The BMJ Skip to main content
Intended for healthcare professionals Access provided by Google Indexer Subscribe My …

Is the cure really worse than the disease? The health impacts of lockdowns during COVID-19

G Meyerowitz-Katz, S Bhatt, O Ratmann, JM Brauner… - BMJ global …, 2021 - gh.bmj.com
The claims often include the idea that the benefits of lockdowns on infection control may be
outweighed by the negative impacts on the economy, social structure, education and mental …

How Many Lives Has Lockdown Saved in the UK?

R Nyman, P Ormerod - medRxiv, 2020 - medrxiv.org
We compare the trajectory of deaths (both in hospitals and care homes) on a daily basis in
Sweden and England and Wales (which constitute 90 per cent of the UK population) from 11 …

The case against lockdown as a public health intervention

M Woolhouse - Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of …, 2022 - journals.sagepub.com
Woolhouse 13 dropping measures that have limited public benefit, such as banning outdoor
activities12 or closing schools. 13 Though this was understood by epidemiologists from very …

Lockdowns only slightly postponed deaths in New Zealand

J Gibson - 61st Annual Conference of the New …, 2021 - researchcommons.waikato.ac.nz
The Level 4 lockdown imposed on March 25 2020 in New Zealand was the world's most
restrictive set of closure and containment policies at the time. While designed to deal with …

“Stay at Home, Protect the National Health Service, Save Lives”: A cost benefit analysis of the lockdown in the United Kingdom

DK Miles, M Stedman, AH Heald - International Journal of …, 2021 - Wiley Online Library
Introduction The COVID‐19 pandemic has transformed lives across the world. In the UK, a
public health driven policy of population “lockdown” has had enormous personal and …

Was lockdown necessary?

K Yates - bmj, 2022 - bmj.com
Was lockdown necessary? Page 1 Was lockdown necessary? Two years on from the UK's first
covid lockdown, Kit Yates looks at whether it could have been avoided Kit Yates senior lecturer …