Merlin and Solomon: Lessons from the law's formative encounters with forensic identification science

MJ Saks - Hastings Lj, 1997 - HeinOnline
Scientific expert opinion is a specie of evidence that presents the courts with a challenging
set of paradoxes and dilemmas. Consider: Scientific expert testimony is usually welcomed …

Defining the Task at Hand: Non-Science Forensic Science after Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael

DM Risinger - Wash. & Lee L. Rev., 2000 - HeinOnline
/. The Lessons o/Kumho Tire Co. v. Carmichael The 1970s and early 1980s were aperiod of
virtually unbridled expansion of asserted expertise in civil and criminal courtrooms, limited …

Forensic science evidence in question

M Redmayne, P Roberts, C Aitken… - Criminal Law …, 2011 - rke.abertay.ac.uk
How should forensic scientists and other expert witnesses present their evidence in court?
What kinds and quality of data can experts properly draw on in formulating their …

Anecdotal forensics, phrenology, and other abject lessons from the history of science

DL Faigman - Hastings LJ, 2007 - HeinOnline
Forensic identification has long been a core component of the criminal justice system.
Practitioners of forensic identification typically claim a scientific basis for the technologies …

Probability, individualization, and uniqueness in forensic science evidence-listening to the academies

DH Kaye - Brook. L. Rev., 2009 - HeinOnline
These are dark days for the forensic sciences. Newspaper and magazine articles, op-ed
headlines, television news, and radio talk shows refer to the field as" seriously deficient,"'a" …

The scientific reinvention of forensic science

JJ Koehler, JL Mnookin… - Proceedings of the …, 2023 - National Acad Sciences
Forensic science is undergoing an evolution in which a long-standing “trust the examiner”
focus is being replaced by a “trust the scientific method” focus. This shift, which is in progress …

Science and Technology Studies on Trial:: Dilemmas of Expertise

M Lynch, S Cole - Expert Evidence and Scientific Proof in Criminal …, 2017 - taylorfrancis.com
This paper discusses materials from a legal case, People v. Hyatt (2001). This was a
criminal case in which one of the authors (Simon Cole) agreed to appear as an expert …

Forensic science: Grand goals, tragic flaws, and judicial gatekeeping

JC Moriarty, MJ Saks - Judges J., 2005 - HeinOnline
Identification/quantitation versus individualization. An important distinction exists among the
forensic sciences. The identification/quantitation specialties typically are derived from …

A contextual approach to the admissibility of the state's forensic science and medical evidence

G Edmond, K Roach - University of Toronto Law Journal, 2011 - utpjournals.press
This article examines the admissibility of forensic science and medicine in criminal
proceedings. In Part ii, we explain how reliability-based admissibility standards in the United …

Commentary on the need for a research culture in the forensic sciences

P Margot - UCLA L. Rev., 2010 - HeinOnline
It is difficult for me to comment on an article written by such eminent and high-profile authors
on the need for a research culture in the forensic sciences. Apparently, these authors have …