Thomson 50 Years Later: Consensus and Controversy

ER Crozat - American Philosophical Quarterly, 2024 - scholarlypublishingcollective.org
Approximately 50 years have passed since Judith Jarvis Thomson wrote A Defense of
Abortion (1971). Her article has significantly shaped the philosophical literature on abortion …

A defense of abortion

JJ Thomson - Ethics: Contemporary Readings, 2004 - api.taylorfrancis.com
Judith Jarvis Thomson, an American philosopher born in 1929, works in ethics and
philosophy of mind. Her article on abortion is one of the most widely reprinted essays of …

[引用][C] Fiddling Second: Reflections on A Defense of Abortion

N Davis - 2001 - direct.mit.edu
“A Defense of Abortion” was initially published in the inaugural issue of Philosophy & Public
Affairs in the fall of 1971. It had an immediate impact on philosophers' discussions of …

Nature as demonic in Thomson's defense of abortion

JT Wilcox - The New Scholasticism, 1989 - pdcnet.org
Thomson, is now" the most widely reprinted essay in all oi contemporary philosophy." 2 It
must be important. Nevertheless, though referenees to it are common, and though many …

[引用][C] A Defence of Abortion; A Question for Judith Jarvis Thomson

PW Bennett - Philosophical Investigations, 1982 - Wiley Online Library
Does the foetus use the body of the woman who has it in the same way that the violinist is
using the body of the unwilling kidney donor? Thomson takes it for granted that the relation …

Re-reading Thomson: Thomson's unanswered challenge

M Watkins - 2006 - philpapers.org
I show that the common reading of Thomson, that she argues by analogy for the conclusion
that abortion is permissible, is mistaken. The correct reading of Thomson is that she argues …

Thomson and the current state of the abortion controversy

DS Levin - Journal of Applied Philosophy, 1985 - Wiley Online Library
Many philosophers who wish to defend abortion, but who have become frustrated by the
resistance of the personhood question to yield to any nonarbitrary solution welcomed Judith …

On an inconsistency in Thomson's abortion argument

RF Gibson - Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for …, 1984 - JSTOR
In response to this argument, Thomson asks what is meant by the crucial expression'right to
life'. After rejecting two inadequate semantical analyses, 2 she settles on a third, her" …

How Not to Argue About Abortion

S Griffith - Philosophy Research Archives, 1985 - pdcnet.org
The most iUlportant contribution which professional philosophers could make to the debate
concerning abortion would be to produce a detailed conceptual analysis of the sorts of …

Defusing the Violinist Analogy.

M Lu - Human Life Review, 2013 - search.ebscohost.com
The article presents the author's insights on the argument of Judith Jarvis Thomson in her
article" A Defense of Abortion," which is the most influential philosophical paper on abortion …