Background:

Many options for free tissue transfer have been described for head and neck reconstruction. While functional outcomes remain paramount, aesthetic considerations like color match can be equally consequential for patient quality of life. It is important to understand differences in color match based on flap donor site for head and neck reconstruction.

Methods:

A retrospective review was performed of patients who underwent head and neck reconstruction with free tissue transfer at a tertiary care academic medical center between November 2012 and November 2020. Patients with documented pictures of their reconstruction and external skin paddles were considered. Patient demographics and surgery specific factors were recorded. Objective differences in color match were obtained by calculating the International Commission on Illumination Delta E 2000 (dE2000) score. Standard univariate descriptive statistics and multivariable statistical analyses were performed.

Results:

Lateral arm, parascapular, and medial sural artery perforator (MSAP) free tissue transfer performed favorably compared to other donor sites, whereas anterolateral thigh flaps had the highest average dE2000 scores. Differences in dE2000 scores were mitigated by post-operative radiation to the flap site and with increasing time beyond 6 months post-operatively.

Conclusions:

We provide an objective assessment of external skin color match in patients undergoing free tissue transfer for head and neck cancer by donor site. MSAP, lateral arm, and parascapular free flaps performed well compared to traditional donor sites. These differences are more significant at the face and mandible when compared to the neck, but diminish 6 months after surgery and with post-operative radiation to the free flap skin paddle.