Many studies assume that all ant species collecting extrafloral nectar defend plants against herbivores, although ant–plant interactions are facultative, generalized and have variable outcomes. With over 280 h of observations in an area of Rupestrian Grasslands (Ouro Preto, Brazil), we described the network of interactions between 2313 ants of 23 species and 200 plants of 10 species. Ants from all species were further submitted to an identical task of finding and removing a standardized herbivore surrogate (termites) to quantify the relative protection effectiveness of different ant species. We then correlated ant protection to the volume and concentration of sugar in the nectar as conditional factors and the herbivory damage as interaction outcome. We found that 11 of the 23 species of ants attacked and removed 933 of 2000 termites. All plant species interacted with effective ant protectors, although the identity of the best protector varied among plants. The degree of ant protection was positively associated with sugar concentration of nectar, which further explained the variation in leaf damage among plant species. Our study provides evidence that ant protection varies among ant species and is enhanced by the plant investment in nectar reward, resulting in less herbivory for the partner plant. We also showed that the most protecting ant species are those that are most connected and thus spread the benefit throughout the network.