2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) is an herbicide commonly used in aquatic and terrestrial environments that is degraded by bacteria through the TFD pathway. Previous work has relied on culture-based methods to develop primers for qPCR analysis of the gene cassette in environmental samples. In this study, we combined molecular and genomic approaches to examine the accuracy of established tfdA qPCR primers on environmental samples and update the phylogeny of tfdA genes detected in bacterial genomes. We found most putative 2,4-D degraders are within the Proteobacteria but also found several novel degraders including members of the phyla Candidatus Rokubacteria and Candidatus Eremiobacteraeota. In silico analysis of established primers showed potential amplification of < 5% of putative degrader sequences but 52-100% of experimentally verified degraders when allowing for three and one mismatches between template and primer sequences, respectively. Overall, our work expands the diversity of putative 2,4-D degraders and demonstrates the limitations of culture-based tools for investigating functional diversity of microorganisms in the environment.

Cultivation-based methods can misrepresent the diversity of environmental microorganisms. Our work showcases one example of how culture-based development of molecular tools underestimates the full spectrum of 2,4-D degrading microorganisms. Accurately identifying microorganisms with 2,4-D degradation potential is crucial for understanding the biodegradation potential of a commonly used herbicide across terrestrial, aquatic, and subsurface environments. Additionally, this work reinforces well-documented pitfalls associated with relying on cultured representatives when constructing primers and the challenges of translating findings from a few cultured representatives to understudied or unknown microorganisms in complex environments.