DOCUMENT RESUME ********************************************************************** Page
1 DOCUMENT RESUME ED 350 831 FL 020 530 AUTHOR Skelton, John TITLE Comments in …

Peer review is the primary means of ensuring the maintenance of standards that are
deemed appropriate for scientific publications. There are many similarities, but also some …

Abstract Supports Newman's (1966) suggestions for improving evaluation procedures,
focusing on removing the anonymity of reviewers of submitted papers. Identification of …

This article describes examples of influential and/or highly cited papers that were initially
rejected by one or more scientific journals. The work reported in eight of the papers …

Comments that M. Boor's (1986) suggestions to improve articles published in professional
journals are unsubstantiated guesses and urges Boor to research his ideas. An example …

There are many sides to every ques-tion and as far as the reviewing of books is concerned
there are at least five points of view which are obviously different: the points of view of the …

In this article a quantitative study is reported on the resistance that scientists may encounter
when they do innovative work or when they attempt to publish articles that later become …

Present remarks by the editor as he comes to the end of a six year tenure as editor and two
and half years as associate editor. He takes the opportunity to discuss the organizational …

Examined interjudge reliability of ratings made by members of a program committee for
research presentations at professional meetings. The committee included 18 prominent …

As is the case with other fields, there is motivation for studying the impact that the body of
evaluation theory literature has within and outside the field. The authors used journal articles …