The impairment argument against abortion

P Hendricks - Agency, pregnancy and persons, 2022 - taylorfrancis.com
In this chapter, I present the Impairment Argument, which purports to show that abortion is
immoral even if the fetus is not a person. What drives the argument is the fact that nonlethally …

Fine-tuning the impairment argument

BP Blackshaw, P Hendricks - Journal of medical ethics, 2021 - jme.bmj.com
Perry Hendricks' original impairment argument for the immorality of abortion is based on the
impairment principle: if impairing an organism to some degree is immoral, then ceteris …

Impairing the impairment argument

K van Oosterum, EJ Curran - Journal of Medical Ethics, 2024 - jme.bmj.com
Blackshaw and Hendricks have recently developed and defended the impairment argument
against abortion, arguing that the immorality of giving a child fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) …

The Impairment Argument and Future-Like-Ours: A Problematic Dependence

C Bobier - Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2023 - Springer
In response to criticism of the impairment argument for the immorality of abortion, Bruce
Blackshaw and Perry Hendricks appeal to Don Marquis's future-like-ours (FLO) account of …

Strengthened impairment argument does not restate Marquis

BP Blackshaw - Journal of medical ethics, 2021 - jme.bmj.com
With Perry Hendricks, I recently outlined a strengthened version of the impairment argument
(SIA) for the immorality of abortion. Alex Gillham has argued that our use of Don Marquis' …

Impairment Arguments, Interests, and Circularity

S Napier - The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for …, 2024 - academic.oup.com
A common justification for abortion rights is that the death of the fetus does not violate any of
the fetus's time-relative interests. The time-relative interest account (TRIA) of harm and …

Strengthened impairment argument: restating Marquis?

A Gillham - Journal of medical ethics, 2021 - jme.bmj.com
Blackshaw and Hendricks recently developed a strengthened version of the impairment
argument (SIA) that imports Marquis' account of the wrongness of abortion. I then argued …

Killing and impairing fetuses

P Singh - The New Bioethics, 2022 - Taylor & Francis
Could it be that if a fetus is not a person abortion is still immoral? One affirmative answer
comes in the form of 'The Impairment Argument', which utilizes 'The Impairment Principle'to …

[HTML][HTML] The SIA Can't Just Go with the FLO

J Slater - HEC Forum, 2023 - Springer
Hendricks (2018) has defended an argument that abortion is (usually) immoral, which he
calls the impairment argument. This argument purports to apply regardless of the moral …

Three Problems with the Impairment Argument

W Simkulet - Asian Bioethics Review, 2023 - Springer
In his recent article “Even if the fetus is not a person, abortion is immoral: The Impairment
Argument,” Perry Hendricks sets out to sidestep thorny metaphysical questions regarding …