Virtues Suffice for Argument Evaluation

A Aberdein - Informal Logic, 2023 - erudit.org
The virtues and vices of argument are now an established part of argumentation theory.
They have helped direct attention to hitherto neglected aspects of how we argue. However, it …

Bogency and goodacies: On argument quality in virtue argumentation theory

F Paglieri - Informal Logic, 2015 - informallogic.ca
Virtue argumentation theory (VAT) has been charged of being incomplete, given its alleged
inability to account for argument cogency in virtue-theoretical terms. Instead of defending …

Other-regarding virtues and their place in virtue argumentation theory

F Oliveira de Sousa - Informal Logic, 2020 - erudit.org
In this paper, I argue that, despite the progress made in recent years, virtue argumentation
theory still lacks a more systematic acknowledgment of other-regarding virtues. A fuller …

Virtue and argument: Taking character into account

T Bowell, J Kingsbury - Informal Logic, 2013 - ojs.uwindsor.ca
In this paper we consider the prospects for an account of good argument that takes the
character of the arguer into consideration. We conclude that although there is much to be …

Virtue, in context

DH Cohen - Informal Logic, 2013 - informallogic.ca
Virtue argumentation theory provides the best framework for accommodating the notion of
an argument that is “fully satisfying” in a robust and integrated sense. The process of …

Arguing as a virtuous arguer would argue

JÁ Gascón - Informal Logic, 2015 - ojs.uwindsor.ca
A virtue approach to argumentation would focus on the arguers' character rather than the
arguments. Therefore, it must be explained how good arguments relate to virtuous arguers …

Virtuous arguers: Responsible and reliable

JÁ Gascón - Argumentation, 2018 - Springer
Virtuous arguers are expected to manifest virtues such as intellectual humility and open-
mindedness, but from such traits the quality of arguments does not immediately follow …

Virtues, evidence, and ad hominem arguments

P Bondy - Informal Logic, 2015 - ojs.uwindsor.ca
Abstract Argumentation theorists are beginning to think of ad hominem arguments as
generally legitimate. Virtue argumentation theorists argue that a character trait approach to …

Argumentational virtues and incontinent arguers

I Drehe - Topoi, 2016 - Springer
Abstract Argumentation virtue theory is a new field in argumentation studies. As in the case
of virtue ethics and virtue epistemology, the study of virtue argumentation draws its …

The incompleteness problem for a virtue-based theory of argumentation

B MacPherson - 2013 - scholar.uwindsor.ca
The incompleteness problem for virtue ethics is inherited by a virtue-based theory of
argumentation as developed by Daniel Cohen (2007). A complete normative theory of …