The moral significance of abortion inconsistency arguments

W Simkulet - Asian Bioethics Review, 2022 - Springer
Most opponents of abortion (OA) believe fetuses matter. Critics argue that OA act
inconsistently with regards to fetal life, seeking to restrict access to induced abortion, but …

Why inconsistency arguments matter

J Shaw - The New Bioethics, 2022 - Taylor & Francis
Abortion opponents are sometimes accused of having inconsistent beliefs, actions, and/or
priorities. If they were consistent, they would regard spontaneous abortions to be a greater …

The inconsistency argument: why apparent pro-life inconsistency undermines opposition to induced abortion

W Simkulet - Journal of Medical ethics, 2022 - jme.bmj.com
Most opposition to induced abortion turns on the belief that human fetuses are persons from
conception. On this view, the moral status of the fetus alone requires those in a position to …

Three Problems with the Impairment Argument

W Simkulet - Asian Bioethics Review, 2023 - Springer
In his recent article “Even if the fetus is not a person, abortion is immoral: The Impairment
Argument,” Perry Hendricks sets out to sidestep thorny metaphysical questions regarding …

Miscarriage can kill… but it usually does Not: evaluating inconsistency arguments

JA Bohn - The New Bioethics, 2021 - Taylor & Francis
Recent publications debate the value of inconsistency arguments. Here, I argue that 'Cause
of Death Arguments'—inconsistency arguments that claim miscarriage causes death far …

Inconsistency arguments still do not matter

BP Blackshaw, N Colgrove, D Rodger - Journal of Medical ethics, 2022 - jme.bmj.com
William Simkulet has recently criticised Colgrove et al's defence against what they have
called inconsistency arguments—arguments that claim opponents of abortion (OAs) act in …

Killing and impairing fetuses

P Singh - The New Bioethics, 2022 - Taylor & Francis
Could it be that if a fetus is not a person abortion is still immoral? One affirmative answer
comes in the form of 'The Impairment Argument', which utilizes 'The Impairment Principle'to …

Constructing the Abortion Argument

R Rhodes - The Oxford Handbook of Reproductive Ethics, 2016 - books.google.com
In the 1970s and 1980s, the period shortly before and after Roe v. Wade, 410 US 113
(1973), the landmark decision by the United States Supreme Court on the permissibility of …

Two stalemates in the philosophical debate about abortion and why they cannot be resolved using analogical arguments

C Kaposy - Bioethics, 2012 - Wiley Online Library
Philosophical debate about the ethics of abortion has reached stalemate on two key issues.
First, the claim that foetuses have moral standing that entitles them to protections for their …

Why abortion is immoral.

D Marquis - Bioethics: An Anthology, 2006 - books.google.com
Also, this essay will neglect issues of great importance to a complete ethics of abortion.
Some anti‐-abortionists will allow that certain abortions, such as abortion before …