Narrative assessments in higher education: a scoping review to identify evidence-based quality indicators

M Chakroun, VR Dion, K Ouellet, A Graillon… - Academic …, 2022 - journals.lww.com
Purpose Narrative comments are increasingly used in assessment to document trainees'
performance and to make important decisions about academic progress. However, little is …

Using Natural Language Processing to Evaluate the Quality of Supervisor Narrative Comments in Competency-Based Medical Education

M Spadafore, Y Yilmaz, V Rally, TM Chan… - Academic …, 2023 - journals.lww.com
Purpose Learner development and promotion rely heavily on narrative assessment
comments, but narrative assessment quality is rarely evaluated in medical education …

Predictors of faculty narrative evaluation quality in medical school clerkships

CJ Mooney, JM Pascoe, AE Blatt, VJ Lang… - Medical …, 2022 - Wiley Online Library
Introduction Narrative approaches to assessment provide meaningful and valid
representations of trainee performance. Yet, narratives are frequently perceived as vague …

Education research: a long-term faculty development initiative improves specificity and usefulness of narrative evaluations of clerkship students

CJ Mooney, SJ Powell, S Dahl, C Eiduson… - Neurology® …, 2022 - AAN Enterprises
Background and Objectives Narrative-based evaluations are increasingly used to
discriminate between levels of trainee performance, yet barriers to high-quality narratives …

The McMaster Narrative Comment Rating Tool: Development and Initial Validity Evidence

N McGuire, A Acai, RR Sonnadara - Teaching and Learning in …, 2023 - Taylor & Francis
Abstract Construct The McMaster Narrative Comment Rating Tool aims to capture critical
features reflecting the quality of written narrative comments provided in the medical …

Novel In-Training Evaluation Report in an Internal Medicine Residency Program: Improving the Quality of the Narrative Assessment

M Gutierrez, K Wilson, B Bickford… - Journal of Medical …, 2023 - journals.sagepub.com
OBJECTIVE To determine whether incorporating our novel in-training evaluation report
(ITER), which prompts each resident to list at least three self-identified learning goals …

Examining Generalizability of Faculty Members' Narrative Assessments

CJ Mooney, RT Stone, L Wang, AE Blatt… - Academic …, 2023 - journals.lww.com
Purpose: Narrative assessment of trainees can provide meaningful and valid
representations of performance, 1 yet significant barriers remain to their quality. 2 Although …

[HTML][HTML] Quality of Narratives in Assessment: Piloting a List of Evidence-Based Quality Indicators

M Chakroun, VR Dion, K Ouellet… - … on Medical Education, 2023 - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
ABSTRACT Background & Need for Innovation: Appraising the quality of narratives used in
assessment is challenging for educators and administrators. Although some quality …

[HTML][HTML] Focus: Medical Education: Reviewing the Reviewer: Medical Student Course Feedback as a Marker of Professional Identity Formation

E Brennan-Wydra, JA Encandela… - The Yale Journal of …, 2020 - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Professional identity formation refers to the process by which medical trainees develop and
internalize their new roles. In this work, we analyze medical student evaluations of teaching …