Prolife hypocrisy: why inconsistency arguments do not matter

N Colgrove, BP Blackshaw, D Rodger - Journal of medical ethics, 2021 - jme.bmj.com
Opponents of abortion are often described as 'inconsistent'(hypocrites) in terms of their
beliefs, actions and/or priorities. They are alleged to do too little to combat spontaneous …

Abortion and Ectogenesis: moral compromise

W Simkulet - Journal of Medical Ethics, 2020 - jme.bmj.com
The contemporary philosophical literature on abortion primarily revolves around three
seemingly intractable debates, concerning the (1) moral status of the fetus,(2) scope of …

Cursed lamp: the problem of spontaneous abortion

W Simkulet - Journal of medical ethics, 2017 - jme.bmj.com
Many people believe human fetuses have the same moral status as adult human persons,
that it is wrong to allow harm to befall things with this moral status, and thus voluntary …

The inconsistency argument: why apparent pro-life inconsistency undermines opposition to induced abortion

W Simkulet - Journal of Medical ethics, 2022 - jme.bmj.com
Most opposition to induced abortion turns on the belief that human fetuses are persons from
conception. On this view, the moral status of the fetus alone requires those in a position to …

Moral status and the architects of principlism

F Beckwith, AK Thornton - … of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum …, 2020 - academic.oup.com
In this article, we discuss Beauchamp and Childress's treatment of the issue of moral status.
In particular, we (1) introduce the five different perspectives on moral status that Beauchamp …

Miscarriage, abortion, and disease

T Waters - The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for …, 2023 - academic.oup.com
The frequency of death from miscarriage is very high, greater than the number of deaths
from induced abortion or major diseases., Philosophical Studies 174: 1217–26) argues that …

On The Problem of Defending Basic Equality: Natural Law and The Substance View

H Friberg-Fernros - The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A …, 2023 - academic.oup.com
While most theorists agree with the claim that human beings have high and equal moral
standing, there are strong disagreements about how to justify this claim. These …

Miscarriage can kill… but it usually does Not: evaluating inconsistency arguments

JA Bohn - The New Bioethics, 2021 - Taylor & Francis
Recent publications debate the value of inconsistency arguments. Here, I argue that 'Cause
of Death Arguments'—inconsistency arguments that claim miscarriage causes death far …

Substance, rights, value, and abortion

W Simkulet - Bioethics, 2019 - Wiley Online Library
Most serious contemporary opposition to abortion is grounded on the belief that human
fetuses are members of the same moral category as beings like us, and that the loss of any …

The Two tragedies argument

W Simkulet - Journal of Medical Ethics, 2019 - jme.bmj.com
Opposition to induced abortion rests on the belief that fetuses have a moral status
comparable to beings like us, and that the loss of such a life is tragic. Antiabortion, or pro-life …